Student Solution

-->

"Education is the most powerful weapon which you can use to change the world”
– Nelson Mandela

1 University

1 Course

2 Subjects

Class Discussion about Cathedral

Class Discussion about Cathedral

Q Purpose In this discussion I would like you to practice interpreting a story. Instructions Add a new discussion topic in this forum by (to do so, just click the "reply" button below). In your post please include the following: Procedure: 1. Since you will not be attending class for four hours a week, these discussions are an important part of cultivating your understanding of the stories. Please read the stories twice and respond carefully to the prompts below. Of course—be super polite and respond to others as you would have them respond to you. 2. In order to see your classmates’ responses, you will need to upload any two your homework responses. Once you have uploaded your responses, read through your classmates’ responses and take note of any comments that improve, question, or modify your understanding of the story. 3. Everyone is required to have three posts to at least two different classmates. Please write 3-6 sentences for each of the two classmates. You may start by expressing agreement and then explain how the response helps your understanding of the story. You may ask questions about someone’s interpretation but please avoid stating that a particular comment is wrong. Instead, just thank each other for sharing and then give your own interpretation. A lot of learning can take place when we listen to others and then modify and improve our own understanding. The homework prompts: You may quote and paste any three responses from your homework. 1. Make notes about the setting of the story. What details about the physical setting and time period are given? Follow the narrator from his position in the house looking out the window at the blind man, to his eating at the table, and then moving to another room to watch TV. The TV, of course is part of the setting. The end of the story is interesting with regards to setting as well. 2. What is the conflict in the story? Is it internal or external (within the character or between characters or between a character and some situation)? Explain it clearly. (Write about 2-3 sentences.) 3. Choose two short passages from the story (one important sentence, for example and put quotation marks around each). Write a few sentences about each in which you draw some conclusions about the significance and meaning. 4. What do you think is a major theme of the story? Write this out as a complex idea about the story, about its significance a meaning. (One complex sentence.) Netiquette Please practice "netiquette" in all your communications. • Be kind and respectful to others. • Use full sentences. • Avoid jargon and acronyms. • Use language that supports others. Discussion Rubric To view the grading rubric for this discussion, click on the "more options" icon (3 vertical dots at the top) and then select "show rubric". Mobile App users: Click Grades, then click into the Discussion. The rubric can then be found on the Grades tab. Aim for excellence! These are the criteria for what comprises an "Excellent" rating for a discussion post: • Addresses each part of the discussion prompt(s). • Postings demonstrate reflective and critical thinking, not just recitation of information from textbook. • Makes connections to previous or current course content, or to real-life situations. • Contains insightful and thoughtful ideas, connections, or applications. • Makes reference to textbook or other sources when required. • Well-written and free of spelling and grammatical errors. • Includes well-written, thoughtful response(s) to classmates. Tips • Click on the ReplyLinks to an external site. box to post a reply to the main discussion. To respond to individual posts, click reply within each thread. • Click on the collapse and expand functions to help you "see" these threads better. You can collapse and expand individual threaded discussions by hovering over the top center of the white box containing the entire reply, and click on the blue arrow that appears. • Check back often as the discussions are dynamic! Click Discussions in the Course Navigation menu to get a quick glance at the active discussions and number of unread posts. Once inside the Discussion, click the Unread button below for a quick way to see new posts. Helpful Resources Canvas Guide Resources How do I reply to a discussion as a student? Canvas Student Guides, Discussion Topic List This video is captioned. Turn on captioning with the CC icon on the lower right of the screen. Note for Instructor: If you have set this discussion up as a group discussion, recommended for creating smaller, manageable group sets of 10-15/group, then keep the following "just-in-time" resources for the students and delete this note. If this is not a group discussion then delete this note and the "Navigation Tip" and video tutorial below. Navigation Tip: This is a group discussion, so you'll notice that the course navigation menu changes (you no longer see Modules). To get back to the course, click on the group name in the "breadcrumb" trail of links at the top, then click on the course name. Be sure to tune into this short video tutorial...it will save you time and frustration later!

View Related Questions

Solution Preview

The main conflict of the story is internal to the narrator. He struggles with preconceived notions of how Robert will act and how he lives his life. Everything about Robert is framed in a negative light, but once the narrator actually meets Robert the real conflict begins. He goes back and forth between praise, surprise, discontent, and eventually peace. Every moment and every interaction at first is met with an aside from the narrator usually adding some sort of snide remark. Towards the end of the story, the snide remarks are gone, and the two men are simply bonding over a drawing.